Study Summary
Women remain underrepresented in leadership positions worldwide, even though gender-diverse leadership is associated with positive organizational outcomes, particularly in times of crisis. This underrepresentation is also evident in Germany and in industries with a high degree of digitalization. While theories such as “think crisis–think female” and the concept of the “glass cliff” focus on the appointment of women to leadership positions during organizational crises, little is known to date about how female leaders themselves retrospectively interpret crisis experiences—both personally and organizationally.
To close this research gap, this study conducted a qualitative investigation based on 22 episodic interviews with female executives from highly digitized industries in Germany, which took place between July and October 2023. Using the GABEK® method, this study reconstructs recurring patterns of interpretation and areas of tension in the participants’ narratives. The results show that crises are experienced less as isolated events and more as cumulative, biographically embedded processes that span personal, professional, and organizational domains. Health-related stress, moral conflicts, challenges to legitimacy, and organizational instability overlap over time and are primarily recognized as crises through retrospective interpretation.
In contrast to vocation-centered theories of crisis leadership, crisis contexts often reinforce existing hierarchies and gender-specific power structures rather than opening up leadership opportunities for women. Leadership in crises is therefore not interpreted as a specifically female leadership style, but rather as a relationship-oriented and meaning-making practice shaped by biography, organizational context, and persistent uncertainty.
Building on these findings and emphasizing lived experiences as well as retrospective meaning-making, this study contributes to gender studies in the context of crisis leadership, by conceptualizing crisis leadership as an ongoing, situational process of interpretation embedded in the biographical trajectories of leaders, rather than as a mere reaction to isolated crisis events or leadership appointments.
Key findings of this study
- Cumulative crisis experience: Female leaders rarely experiencecrises as isolated events, but rather as cumulative, biographically embedded processes. Health-related stress, moral conflicts, and organizational instability overlap over time.
- Consolidation of existing structures: Contrary to theories such as the “glass cliff,” crisis contexts rarely open up new opportunities for women to advance. Instead, crises often reinforce existing power structures, while diversity initiatives are temporarily suspended.
- Relationship-Oriented Meaning-Making: Crisis leadership is not understood as a distinctively feminine leadership style, but rather as a relationship-oriented and meaning-making practice. Empathy, open communication, and team involvement provide employees with guidance during periods of high uncertainty.
- The Ambivalence of Empathy: Relationship-oriented leadership proves to be an ambivalent resource under sustained pressure. While empathy provides support, it simultaneously increases the emotional strain and the risk of burnout for leaders.
- Conscious Boundary-Setting: To safeguard their own resilience, leaders set clear boundaries and realign their roles. Organizations should structurally recognize this emotional labor and establish reliable support systems.